Are Lotteries Serving the Public Good?

A lottery is a game of chance operated by a state government in which the prize is cash or goods. The chances of winning are very low, but people play the lottery for many reasons: they enjoy it, they want to get rich, or they think that if they win the jackpot their problems will be solved (as evidenced by all the billboards advertising Powerball and Mega Millions). Whatever the reason, lotteries are an important source of state revenue and continue to grow in popularity. The question is whether they are serving the public good.

The casting of lots to determine fates and distribute property has a long history in human society, including several instances in the Bible. The modern lottery is a more recent invention. It began in Europe during the reign of Augustus Caesar as a way to fund public works projects, and was introduced to the United States by British colonists. Today, it is a multi-billion dollar industry that provides a substantial source of state revenues.

Lottery games vary in structure, but most involve the drawing of numbers to determine winners and the amount of the prizes. The more numbers matched, the higher the prize. Some states have a “joker” number that increases the odds of winning. In addition to state-sponsored lotteries, there are privately operated lotteries and internet-based gaming sites that offer the same types of games.

Generally, the prize pool is comprised of the amount remaining after expenses and profits for the promoter are deducted from the total value of tickets sold. The prize money is usually determined by the state before the lottery is launched. It may be set in advance or the prize amounts may be predetermined and the winner selected by a random process, such as the drawing of a single ticket.

In order to maximize revenues, lottery officials must advertise heavily in order to attract players and increase participation. This promotion of gambling can have negative consequences for poor people and problem gamblers, but it is also at cross-purposes with the broader public interest.

State governments, in their efforts to sell lotteries, argue that they are a valuable source of “painless” revenue, since players are voluntarily spending their money, rather than being taxed directly by the state. This argument has been remarkably effective, especially during times of economic stress, when voters fear that state governments are raising taxes or cutting vital public services.

However, the fact is that lotteries are an expensive way for a government to raise money and do not provide much benefit in return for this expenditure. Most importantly, they encourage the covetousness of people by promising them that their life would be greatly improved if only they won the jackpot. This is contrary to the biblical prohibition against covetousness: “You shall not covet your neighbor’s house, his wife, his male or female servant, his ox or donkey, or anything that is his. It is all the curse of the Lord” (Exodus 20:17). The truth is that people will not stop playing the lottery even if they are made aware of the facts about it.